Victor Furman, op-ed
Press & Sun-Bulletin
The State of Delaware has confirmed a link between a coal-burning plant and an increase in cancer among exposed residents. The Delaware News Journal reports that years after citizen activists first asked the state to investigate the problem, the Delaware Division of Public Health has finally confirmed what the activists suspected: There’s a cluster of cancer cases near a coal-burning plant, the state’s worst polluter.
The coal-burning plant is NRG Energy Inc.’s Indian River complex and is located in Millsboro, Delaware. The study was conducted by examining the cancer cases in a six ZIP code area around the plant. The areas examined were Dagsboro, Frankford, Georgetown, Millsboro, Ocean View and Selbyville.
The Division of Public Health study showed an incidence of 553.9 cancer cases per 100,000 residents of this area between 2000 and 2004 compared with the Delaware state rate of 501.3 and the U.S. rate of 473.6 cancer cases per 100,000 residents. Thus, this study confirmed that the rate of cancer cases in this area is 17 percent higher than the national average.
According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Toxic Release Inventory, coal-burning power plants in Delaware release large amounts of toxic hydrochloric acid, sulfuric acid, ammonia and hydrogen fluoride, along with lead, nickel and mercury compounds and other chemicals that may cause cancer or linger in human tissues or the environment.
No government study would be complete without a qualification blaming the exposed people. The Delaware study is no exception. In the study, the highest incidence of cancer among the exposed residents was lung cancer, which accounted for 19.5 percent of the cases. The Division of Public Health said that it is not sure whether the higher incidence of lung cancer could have been caused by tobacco or by people having moved into the area from a different environment.
The report also said that new state rules intended to reduce emissions “are a major step forward in providing a clean environment.” With this, we agree.
Does any of this sound familiar? As you may know, citizen activists first uncovered an unusual cluster of polycythemia vera cases along the Ben Titus Road in the Still Creek area of Rush Township. Polycythemia vera is a rare bone marrow cancer.
Two cancer studies by the Pennsylvania Department of Health (PA DOH) left the affected residents with little information of significance about the rates of cancer in the area or the cause of the polycythemia vera. The PA DOH attributed any increases in the incidences of cancer that did appear in its two studies to life style, specifically smoking and diet. The PA DOH was partially correct. The increases can be attributed to life style but in these studies the life style relates to living in an area contaminated with imported hazardous wastes and to being exposed to a toxic chemical soup.
A reporter, Sue Sturgis, from North Carolina has reviewed the PA DOH’s data of reported cases of polycythemia vera by county for the years 2001 through 2003 and suggests a possible association between polycythemia vera and power plants that burn waste coal www.hometownhazards.com. It is amazing to us that a reporter from North Carolina has done more investigating into the basis of our problems than the Pennsylvania Department of Health.
Finally, a recent article reported that the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), part of the federal Department of Health and Human Resources, is completing a study on the incidence of polycythemia vera in Carbon, Luzerne and Schuylkill counties. The article reported that the ATSDR has found an almost quadrupling of the incidence of polycythemia vera in the area.
The primary purpose of all government is to protect the health, safety and welfare of its citizens. When will our government begin to protect our health, safety and welfare from the toxic emissions of coal-fired power plants? We are not asking that these plants be shut down but we are asking that our legislators stop giving these toxin-emitting plants licenses to pollute. We are demanding that they be operated in a manner that reduces the risks of toxic emissions for the people living near these plants.
*We thank Jill McElheney of the Ministry to Improve Child and Adolescent Health (MICAH’s Mission: Micahmission@aol.com), P.O. Box 275, Winterville, GA 30683, for calling our attention to the study by the Delaware Division of Public Health..
SO YOU thought smoking cigarettes was bad for your health? Try living next to a coal-fired power plant.
That’s the diagnosis that Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR) relayed to the public in a comprehensive medical study released on November 18 called “Coal’s Assault of Human Health.” In it, the organization, comprised of physicians and public health experts, claims that coal pollutants damage every major organ in the human body and contribute to four of the top five leading causes of death in the United States.
Not since NASA’s James Hansen rang the global warming alarm about coal’s major contribution to climate change has there been a more dire call to shut down coal operations in the United States. It is not simply about cleaning up the coal process; it is about halting its production altogether in order to immediately save lives.
From an article in the Socialistic Worker.org:
At every stage in its life cycle, coal can negatively impact human health, from mining operations, cleaning, transportation to burning and disposing of the combustion waste. PSR reports that many Americans are being affected daily by coal and the exposure is contributing to horrible health problems; heart attacks, lung cancer, strokes and asthma, among others.
“The findings of this report are clear: while the U.S. relies heavily on coal for its energy needs, the consequences of that reliance for our health are grave,” said Dr. Alan H. Lockwood, a principal author of the report and a professor of neurology at the University at Buffalo.
From Victor Furman:
As individuals responsible for our own carbon footprint we must look at the feet of the entire energy industry. Coal has the biggest set of feet of all other sources combined. I as many readers know, am an advocate for natural gas and natural gas drilling. I argue points and research every report of any source of problems that are connected to the hydro fracturing process. There are not any reports of water contamination or earth destroying mountain top removal scenario’s to where one can point a finger and say this was caused by fracking. There have been surface spills and production mishaps that were quickly contained and remedied but nothing, I mean nothing that compares with the intentional destruction of lands connected to the minning of coal. There is no comparison to the damage to our lands deforestation and no comparison to the many many many water tables, rivers lakes and streams that have intentionally been polluted by the by prodoct of coal, “coal ash” which has been said to contain more radioactive material then waste from a nuclear power plant as well as lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury and other Total dissolved solids that are harm full to our environment and health.
We are afforded a great opportunity to begin to lift the feet of coal from the surface of our planet for a fossil fuel that is 47 percent cleaner, uses much less water to obtain, and need not have to tear down our mountain tops. and killing our waterways through mining and coal ash dumps. This is not just a bridge to Cleaner Energy, this the cleaner energy to bring us to the promise and development of greener technologies.
Yes I am an advocate for what some are calling a gift from God. And yes I do have land and stand to make money from signing a lease. I welcome those of you who might say my advocacy for natural gas is based on greed to check the deeds office and see that the vast amount of land I own that has promised, according to some, to bring me life changing wealth. What I own is 5 acres of highly taxed land. My real goal is not the monies, but the thought of reducing the carbon emissions that are destroying our earth through anyway necessary so that my grand children wont have to watch there mother or father die of diseases brought on by energy pollution. My family and I lived near a coal fired power plant, My wife died at 42 from cancer of the endocrine system, my daughter was cured from mouth cancer at the age of 15. My other daughter suffers from thyroid problems. was it coal and coal ash dust…. I believe so. Drilling for Natural Gas beats the heck out of drilling and mining for coal.
read online